Specialties: Gorgeous views of the sunsets on Lake Ontario all while enjoying our fine casual dining outside from steaks to the very freshest seafood. Open now : 12:00 PM - 12:00 AM. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Webster Vacation Packages Flights to WebsterCastaways on the Lake: Seafood? - See 321 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. 244 Lake Rd, Webster, NY 14580-1015Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 324 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #36 of 88 restaurants in Webster. Castaways on the Lake: Nice view of lake - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. (315) 668-3434. Dine on tasty appetizers, sandwiches, fresh salads and refreshing desserts. We have a protected marina, private beach, The Home of Gene Miller Guide Service. Castaways on the Lake: Sunset Was The Best Part - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Webster Vacation Packages Flights to WebsterCastaways on the Lake: Dinner in Bar Area - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Coconut Shrimp 1 Photo 14 Reviews Fish Tacos 2 Photos 5 Reviews Coconut Crusted Grouper 4 Photos 4 Reviews Lakeside 2 Photos 3. Castaways on the Lake: Lunch - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. 2114 Grandview • Lake Milton, OH 44429. - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. 244 Lake Rd. Castaways on the Lake. Review of Castaways on the Lake. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #39 of 91 restaurants in Webster. Order Online. Webster. Webster. Castaways on the Lake. - See 322 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Visitors' opinions on The Castaway On Phantom. Call Today! 585-323-2943 244 Lake Road Webster, NY 14580 Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 321 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #37 of 88 restaurants in Webster. Castaways on the Lake: Great setting, lovely deck, decent food - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Immerse yourself in a culinary journey featuring the finest tastes, including regional oysters and market-fresh fish. - See 322 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. The breathtaking views of Lake Erie are paired with the wide variety of seafood options at this waterfront restaurant. More restaurant details. Castaways on the Lake: Long wait and substandard food. Be a guest at your next party and let us do the cooking. Castaways on the Lake: Great, relaxing atmosphere - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Review of Castaways on the Lake. This makes it a suitable spot for those looking to unwind or have a casual get-together with friends. 759. 585-323-2943 244 Lake Road Webster, NY 14580. Castaways on the Lake. Castaways on the Lake: Every time is amazing!!! - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Improve this listing. 6 menu pages, ⭐ 192 reviews, 🖼 65 photos - Castaways On The Lake menu in Webster. Hedges Restaurant | Webster, NY. Details CUISINES Bar, Seafood Meals Lunch, Dinner, Late Night FEATURES Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Takeout, Reservations, Outdoor Seating,. The place was clean. Features a Lunch and Dinner Menu including seafood and appetizers. 6 (44 Reviews)Castaways on the Lake: Meh - See 324 traveler reviews, 69 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. The menu features classic dishes such as beef burgers, New York strip steak, and grilled chicken sandwiches. (585) 323-2943 Visit Website Map & Directions 244 Lake RdWebster, NY 14580. More restaurant details. Castaways on the Lake: Beautiful view, grungy interior, too expensive - See 321 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Warm evenings and daily specials are what make the Castaways a favorite dining destination. m. 244 Lake Rd, Webster, NY 14580-1015. Warm evenings and daily specials are what make the Castaways a favorite dining destination. Warm evenings and daily specials are what make the Castaways a favorite dining destination. Castaways on the Island is an American restaurant located in La Crosse. 69 photos. Description: Gorgeous views of the sunsets on Lake Ontario all while enjoying our fine casual dining outside from steaks to the very freshest seafood. Unclaimed. “ Good neighborhood restaurant ” 01/21/2023. 3422. Webster. “Good food, service and location. m. 302 S Center St. m. Specialties: Make A Reservation through our website to save your seat. Webster Castaways On The Lake View Menus Read Reviews Write Review Directions Castaways On The Lake ($$) 3. IPA - American. Webster. Average food - See 320 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. have partnered together to open Castaway Craig’s Pub & Grub, a family restaurant with a beach inspired atmosphere on the beautiful shore of Craig Beach, Ohio. Website. Webster. Mr. Castaway's Sports Bar & Grill. Castaways, the popular island survival game, has just made its highly anticipated debut on mobile devices in Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. . Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. Enter your address above to see fees, and delivery + pickup estimates. - See 319 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Andy Olson is drinking an IPA by Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar at Castaways Raw Bar & Grill. 759. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Flights to Webster Castaways on the Lake;Castaways on the Lake: Go for the view, not the food. . ”. Webster. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. Rochester's best known waterfront restaurant for over 85 years. 1603 N Lake Shore Dr, Chicago, IL 60614 (773) 281-1200 Visit Website. castaway’s burger $15 served on a hawaiian bun with grilled pineapple, lettuce tomato, pickle, cheddar cheese, bacon & an onion ring drizzled with wang bang sauce. Castaways on the Lake: Great deck overlooking Lake Otario. Gorgeous views of the sunsets on. Website. Castaways on the Lake: Much to be desired. Castaways on the Lake: Local Hangout with Views of Lake Ontario & Irondequoit Bay - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: Bad, just bad. Claim this business. Enjoy the beauty of nature!Castaways on the Lake: Casual place to eat on the lake - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Webster. 69 reviews. Perfect dinner ! Oh and we took a key lime pie slice to go. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Webster Vacation Packages Flights to WebsterCastaways on the Lake: Horrible service. Castaways on the Lake: Sunset Was The Best Part - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Tomahawk Family Restaurant. Email. Nav Menu 8. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Flights to Webster Castaways on the Lake; Things to Do in WebsterCastaways on the Lake: Save your money - One star for the view alone - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. 25131 Blackwater Lane. Our Menu draws from Kirk’s Northeast Coast influences and blends local traditions with a Boston feel. Boat Docking. Castaways on the Lake: Such a view - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: Late dinner - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. 69 photos. Castaways on the Lake: Castaways - $$$ Restaurant with $ food and service - See 321 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Website. The menu features classic dishes such as beef burgers, New York strip steak, and grilled chicken sandwiches. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. Improve this listing. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #45 of 101 restaurants in Webster. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #39 of 91 restaurants in Webster. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #38 of 90 restaurants in Webster. Serving both drinks. Our establishment has been serving the Rochester area since 1906. •. 244 Lake Rd, Webster, NY, United States, New YorCastaways on the Lake: Food is still OK, but too many problems this visit - See 324 traveler reviews, 69 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Lake: Our paylake is a 4 acre lake. Ridge Donut Cafe. Share. Webster. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Flights to Webster Castaways on the Lake; Things to Do in WebsterCastaways on the Lake: Go anywhere else - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Serving tasty appetizers, sandwiches and entrees. Live Music Venue. Castaways on the Lake: good food bad service - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Website. Dominic's at the Lake / Restaurant, Italian, Pub & bar #164 of 3746 places to eat in Rochester. Improve this listing. 13. Castaways on the Lake: Beautiful sunset view - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: Don't Bother - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. skip a meal. Boat Docking. Review. I would give Castaways a 5 for its location on Lake Ontario. “ Always fabulous ” 09/08/2022. Check-out time 10 a. The Castaways, formerly known as the Sandbar Inn. To summarize, Castaways Pizza & Grill, located at 877 Broad St, Conneaut, Ohio, 44030, offers a wide range of tasty food options in an American (New) style. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #3 of 4 restaurants in Cushing. Castaways on the Lake: Great location. Castaways on the Lake. Castaways On The Lake « Back To Webster, NY. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. Warm evenings and daily specials are what make the Castaways a favorite dining destination. Ranked #37 of 103 Restaurants in Webster. 00. Rating · 4. Italian Restaurant. Castaways on the Lake: worst experience! Horrible wait time, service, bad food!! overpriced for quality of food - See 321 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. 324 Reviews. Features a Lunch and Dinner Menu including seafood and appetizers. Castaways on the Lake: FILTHY glassware - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Website. •. 324 Reviews. We have a two tiered lakeside dining deck that offers the perfect setting for outdoor dining, in. Not magnificent food. Castaways on the Lake: Terrible management. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Flights to WebsterCastaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. . Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. Castaways Bar & Grill. OH. With over 30 years of experience, we can cater a wide range of events at our place or yours. Broiled shrimp and sea scallops with tomato, cucumber, red onion, carrots on a bed of fresh greens. Most beer gardens offer a view of the surrounding brick walls, the sites and sounds of the. American Restaurant and Seafood Restaurant $$ $$Castaways Bar & Grill. +1 585-323-2943. . Castaways on the Lake in Webster, NY 14580 is a waterfront restaurant & bar that offers great views while enjoying local favorite meals. Castaways on the Lake: This is a hidden jem of a place. . Improve this listing. (1600N, 200E) Chicago, IL 60614. Warm evenings and daily specials are what make the Castaways a favorite dining destination. We have always enjoyed it. Webster. We have a two tiered lakeside dining deck that offers the perfect setting for outdoor dining, in both. The Lakes Restaurant, Victoria, British Columbia. Castaways on the Lake: I can almost see Canada across the lake. See what we have on offer. Webster. Share it with friends or find your next meal. ( 562 Reviews ) Add Your Business. 244 Lake Rd, Webster, NY 14580-1015. $0 - $20. Price range: $0 - $20. 244 Lake Rd, Webster, NY 14580-1015. With one, two, and three-bedroom cottages, and select dog friendly cottages, Castaways is the perfect place to stay in Astor. 244 Lake Rd Webster NY 14580. Share. Castaways on the Lake: Magnificent setting on the Lake Ontario. Castaways on the Lake: Greatly disappointed - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways On The Lake restaurant Webster address. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Flights to WebsterCastaways On The Lake Castaways On The Lake > Menu Menus: | Menu | Web Menu | Update Menu. View our seasonal menu here. We have a two tiered lakeside dining deck that offers the perfect setting for outdoor dining, in both. Drink and dine outside (or under cover) directly on Lake Ontario with views of the Irondequoit Bay Outlet and spectacular sunsets (checkout the website video and Photo Gallery ). - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: Excellent Experience - See 324 traveler reviews, 69 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. 16 Chicken Wings 10 wings served either sweet and sour or buffalo…. 2. Castaways cottages come in many different layouts to suit any party. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. Seafood, American, Steakhouses $$$$. Castaways on the Lake: Good restaurant for a luncheon - See 321 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: Dinner in Bar Area - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Home. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #39 of 92 restaurants in Webster. Castaways on the Lake: Ok. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 324 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #37 of 88 restaurants in Webster. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #38 of 90 restaurants in Webster. . Castaways on the Lake: Done with this place - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 321 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #38 of 87 restaurants in Webster. • $$ • American • Burgers • Sandwiches. Castaways on the Lake: Castaways - $$$ Restaurant with $ food and service - See 321 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Fax: 352. Elizabeth Carpenter Castaways on the Lake Restaurant Century Liquor and Wines Dr. Castaways on the Lake: GREAT spot to relax - See 324 traveler reviews, 69 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #41 of 93 restaurants in Webster. Astor, Florida 32102. Total 22. Castaways on the Lake: Service very poor, prices way to over priced, - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Fate has propelled the Castaway Wanderers and University of Victoria Vikes into a B. - Filmed With One Camera Angle - Rugby. Save. Castaways on the Lake: Lake View Dinning - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. 27 reviews #1,019 of 2,107 Restaurants in Orlando $$ - $$$ American Bar Pub. 00 Topped with fresh. Share. Warm evenings and daily specials are what make the Castaways a favorite dining destination. Outdated menu here? Click to update. 19 reviews of Castaways "My family and I have been here several times. Lobster Roll 4 Photos 12 Reviews Coconut Shrimp 1 Photo 14 Reviews Fish Tacos 2 Photos 5 Reviews Coconut Crusted Grouper 4 Photos 4 Reviews Lakeside 2 Photos 3 Reviews Location & Hours 244 Lake Rd Webster,. $0 - $20. Home;. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. Improve this listing. Phone: 585-265-3850. Castaways on the Lake: Expensive. Unique 21. . Castaways on the Lake: A small piece of paradise - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: Not great - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Webster Vacation Packages Flights to WebsterCastaways on the Lake: Always good - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Nav Menu 3. The Lakes Restaurant is a local favorite, known for. Castaways on the Lake. Shanghai Resort’s Castaway Grill & Bar. N/A IBU (3. Grilled salmon, mandarin oranges, sliced almonds, fried asian noodles, tomato, cucumber, red onion on a bed of fresh greens with asian ginger dressing. Go for drink. Castaways on the Lake: Food was not very good especially for the price - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Warm evenings and daily specials are what make the Castaways a favorite dining destination. View the Menu of Castaways on the Lake in 244 Lake Rd, Webster, NY. Castaways on the Lake: ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: Great to sit by the Lake - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake. Most beer gardens offer a view of the surrounding brick walls, the sites and sounds of the nearest. Webster. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 321 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #37 of 88 restaurants in Webster. 6 menu pages, ⭐ 192 reviews, 🖼 65 photos - Castaways On The Lake menu in Webster. Sort by: Global Friends You. +1 585-323-2943. Rochester's best know waterfront restaurant for over 85 years. Rochester's best known waterfront restaurant for over 85 years. Castaways on the Lake: EXCELLENT!! - See 322 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways On The Lake at 244 Lake Road in Webster, which has an expansive deck that faces the lake, is high and dry, and ready for visitors. 5. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #1,903 of 8,427 restaurants in Chicago. Castaways on the Lake: Lovely Time - See 324 traveler reviews, 69 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. . Castaways on the Lake: Wasn't Overly Impressed - See 321 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: Disappointing dinner - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Worst ever! - See 320 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Could go in for a lengthier review but in a nutshell: not a knowledgeable staff (bartender could not tell Scotch from Bourbon), poorly stocked bar, deck eating area did not appear very clean with dirty. Webster. 4. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. Improve this listing. Certainly worth the 40 minute drive from our camp at Pymatuning. . 330-557-9005. . 916 County Rte 37, Brewerton, NY 13036 +1 315-668-3434 Website. Castaways on the Lake: Beautiful Sunset and Good Food - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Flights to WebsterCastaways on the Lake: Won't go again - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. About Castaways at Hidden Harbor. Webster. Webster. Castaways on the Lake. 244 Lake Rd, Webster, NY 14580-1015. Providing a destination location for boaters along the shore of Lake Erie. 69 photos. Castaways On the Lake is a seafood restaurant. ”. Webster. 244 Lake Rd, Webster, NY 14580-1015. Castaways on the Lake: Great service - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Enjoy the most spectacular view and gorgeous sunsets on Lake Ontario while dining outside in the Spring & Summer. Castaways on the Lake: Best Lake Views in a casual setting, grab a cold drink and enjoy the view! - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #39 of 92 restaurants in Webster. Castaways on the River has the perfect boat rentals, cottage rentals and motel rooms for a great family vacation in Astor, Fl. Buffalo Sabres Hockey Team Ms. 1,692 likes · 39 talking about this · 2,041 were here. Castaways on the Lake. (585) 323-1224. September 2023. Castaways on the Lake: Just, beautiful! - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Description: Gorgeous views of the sunsets on Lake Ontario all while enjoying our fine casual dining outside from steaks to the very freshest seafood. Flights Vacation Rentals. What cozy, cool place to dine or just to have a drink or two . 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #41 of 92 restaurants in Webster. (585) 323-2943. Castaways on the Lake: Way too overpriced for the - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. In the north of the island there is a camp of castaways where many have gathered, and you can buy some ale at the tavern. Price range: $0 - $20. Unclaimed. 1603 N. Castaways on the Lake. Whether this is your first time in Astor or you are a long time visitor, with our choices of boat rentals you’ll be able to enjoy the wildlife, freshwater fishing, and crystal springs in the surrounding areas. Neptune Salad. Ranked #37 of 109 Restaurants in Webster. Tomorrow: 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm. - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. 59 reviews #8 of 11 Restaurants in Brewerton $$ - $$$ American Steakhouse Bar. Rochester's best known waterfront. View the menu for Castaways Restaurant & Lounge and restaurants in Dover, NH. Choice of dressing. Rochester's best known waterfront restaurant for over 85 years. Phone: 352. Restaurant details. We have a two tiered lakeside dining deck that offers the perfect setting for outdoor dining, in both Spring and Summer. Rebecca Clark Ms. ( 562 Reviews ) Add Your Business. Nav Menu 2. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #41 of 92 restaurants in Webster. Brian, the beer tender, is a great guy and has a fun sense of humor. Castaways on the Lake: Great View and Good Food - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: Dinner with friends - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: Horrible service, questionable food, overpriced with a side of attitude - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. •.